Tuesday, October 3, 2023

Lawsuit Challenges San Juan County Redistricting Map, Citing Violation of Indigenous Voting Rights


Several civil rights advocates filed a lawsuit on Thursday against San Juan County, for adopting a redistricting plan that they say denies San Juan County’s Navajo Nation citizens and other Indigenous voters an equal opportunity to elect representatives of their choice in violation of the Voting Rights Act.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of New Mexico, the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, UCLA Voting Rights Project, and the Navajo Nation Department of Justice and DLA Piper are representing, the Navajo Nation, Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission (NNHRC) and five Navajo voters. The complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District Court of New Mexico. 

According to the suit, the Board of Commissioners’ recently-adopted map severely packs Indigenous voters into one of the five districts, effectively depriving them of an equal opportunity to elect candidates of their choice in the other four districts despite them constituting almost 40 percent of the county’s total population. The Board of Commissioners adopted this map over the express objection of the Navajo Nation, Navajo Nation citizen residents of San Juan County, and the ACLU of New Mexico, and despite the Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission submitting a proposed map that more evenly distributed the Indigenous population across two districts while also better complying with other redistricting criteria than the adopted map.  

While San Juan County’s total population decreased between 2010 and 2020, its Indigenous population increased such that Indigenous people–over 90 percent of whom are citizens of the Navajo Nation–now constitute the largest racial or ethnic group in the county. 

The lawsuit asks the court order to implement a new districting plan for the San Juan County Board of Commissioners that complies with Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act by creating two districts, instead of the one in which Indigenous voters have an equal opportunity to elect representatives of their choice.

“The current redistricting map adopted by San Juan County repeats the long and shameful history of disenfranchising Indigenous communities,” said Preston Sanchez, ACLU of New Mexico's Indigenous Justice Attorney. “The County is obligated under law to ensure that the redistricting process results in Indigenous voters having adequate legislative representation by candidates of their choice. The ACLU of New Mexico will continue to fight any plan that violates the laws, practices and procedures intended to protect the rights of Indigenous voters.”

“The Voting Rights Act was designed to prevent exactly this kind of egregious dilution of the voting power of communities of color,” said Ezra Rosenberg, co-director of the Voting Rights Project of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law. “San Juan County has a legal duty to ensure that all voters have an equal opportunity to elect candidates of their choice. Instead, they have attempted to do the opposite, and this plan must be struck down.”

“The Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission continues to advocate for Navajo voters to elect candidates of their choice in the lawsuit filed against San Juan County, New Mexico. The County Commission adopted a redistricting map that disenfranchises Navajo voters” said Leonard Gorman, Executive Director of Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission. “The Voting Rights Act sets standards for minority societies in the United States, and the Navajo Nation has followed those standards when proposing Navajo Nation maps for San Juan County Commission. The Navajo Nation priority is to maintain compliance with the Voting Rights Act and San Juan County Commission must respect the Voting Rights Act standards and the principals of redistricting when it comes to majority-minority districts.”

“The sovereignty and voting rights of the Navajo people must be respected by local and county governments. The San Juan County Commission chose a map that will significantly divide and lessen the voting power of the largest Sovereign Nation in the United States. The Navajo Nation believes the commissioners have disenfranchised the Native American vote in District 2 and this action does not allow the people to elect a leader of their choice. We will fight to protect the vote of thousands of Indigenous people in northern New Mexico at all costs,” said Speaker Seth Damon (Bááhaalí, Chichiltah, Manuelito, Red Rock, Rock Springs, Tséyatoh).


No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here